In Defense of Keats
“Have you practiced so long to learn to read?
Have you felt so proud to get at the meaning of
poems?” Walt Whitman
In
Benson and Stangroom’s 2006 book, Why Truth Matters, the opening paragraph of the first chapter states:
“Keats told us that Beauty is Truth, Truth Beauty, and that that is all we know
on earth. Romantic poets had many
virtues, but rigor of thought was not always one of them. It’s hard to think of a less true
generalization.”
Of
course, this proclamation by John Keats is paraphrased from the last stanza of
the famous Ode To A Grecian Urn in which
the poet describes a pastoral scene of men and maidens, cut in low relief on a
marble vase:
(O
Attic shape! Fair attitude! With brede
Of
marble men and maidens overwrought,
With forest branches and the trodden
weed;
Thou,
silent form, dost tease us out of thought
As doth eternity. Cold Pastoral!)
And
then, addressing these marble men and maidens on the vase, he brings the poem
to its climactic finish with:
(When
old age shall this generation waste,
Thou
shalt remain, in midst of other woe
Than ours, a friend to man, to whom thou
say’st,
“Beauty
is truth, truth beauty”—that is all
Ye know on earth, and all ye need to
know.)
John
Keats, studied Greek art at the British museum and cultivated a fascination for
Greek marble vases. This
precocious poetic genius who once declared that (The only means of
strengthening one’s intelligence is to make up one’s mind about nothing—to let
the mind be a thoroughfare for all thoughts surely understood—as we all do—that in real life, truth is not always beautiful
and beauty is not always truthful.
In
this most delicate of poems, however, Keats was not generalizing about
life. Rather, he was addressing
the artwork on a Greek marble urn and, from it, generalizing about art where,
indeed, beauty is truth and truth is beauty.
Unlike
life—where truth may be horribly ugly and beauty, dangerously deceiving—art,
which is the honeymoon from life, must be both beautiful and truthful. Pablo Picasso’s Guernica is a painting that
depicts the Nazi German bombing of Guernica, Spain, by twenty-eight bombers, on
April 26, 1937 during the Spanish Civil War. There is nothing beautiful about this ugly massacre, which
killed between 250 and 1600 innocent people and injured many more. In contrast, Picasso’s world-famous
metaphorical rendition of this horrific truth is strikingly beautiful and it is
this eerie symbiosis of truth and beauty that marks the painting’s greatness.
Although
many an artist has attempted to define art, no definition has won wide
acceptance or acclaim. When the
German impressionist painter Max Liebermann (1847-1935) issued his definitive
credo entitled “A Confession of Artistic Faith,” he stated that “To make
visible the invisible: that is what we call art.” In this same
spirit, we could perhaps promulgate that Keats (1795-1821) had indeed coined
the most famous definition of art: “To make truth beautiful and beauty
truthful: that’s what art is all about.”