Preventive Medicine/July&August 2008
Failure of preventive medicine is the cause of
great human misery.
Preventive
medicine is widely applicable, relatively easy, and much more affordable than
individual treatments, which tend to be complicated, often unaffordable, and
frequently limited to the privileged few.
The vernacular wisdom that a bit of prevention is worth a lot of
treatment is even truer today because
industrialization and population growth are relentlessly polluting our tiny
planet.
Sanitation
(clean water and sewage control) is the most essential form of prevention but,
unfortunately, it is currently lacking for the majority of earth’s
population. Preventable infectious
diseases such as Malaria, Tuberculosis, Bilharzia, Aids, Diarrhea, etc. kill
more per year than all our wars combined.
Malnutrition is still a major threat to population health and so is
illiteracy and, although both are preventable, they continue to be widely
prevalent in spite of technological progress.
As
for enlightened individuals living in more affluent microcosms, there are other
preventable diseases that are commonly neglected even though they are readily
detectable with annual physical examinations:
1. High Blood Pressure is a silent killer
because it causes no symptoms.
When untreated, it is the commonest cause of strokes and heart failure;
moreover, it increases the incidence of heart attacks, ruptured aneurisms, and
renal failure. It can only be
detected by measurement and the best measurements are those performed at home
by the vigilant individual because they avoid the common pitfalls of White Coat Hypertension (i.e. doctor’s office) hypertension. If the average of many
home-blood-pressure measurements is >130/80, this is considered
pre-hypertension and requires treatment before it gets worse and more difficult
to control. Home blood-pressure
monitors are widely available and quite reliable. Declining treatment because the individual feels well is the
commonest argument used by those who are not medically enlightened. Reducing salt intake and walking an
hour a day may be all that is needed when pre-hypertension (BP>130/80 and
<140/90) is first diagnosed.
Beyond that point, medications are usually required.
2. Obesity and overweight have reached
epidemic proportions especially in affluent societies. Although treatments abound, there are
no long-term effective medications that have stood the test of time and
science. Overweight causes a
progressive increase in many diseases such as cancer, diabetes, high blood
pressure, high cholesterol, high triglycerides, sleep apnea, heart failure,
back, knee, and hip arthritis, frequent falls, poor surgical outcomes, and
slower recovery from myriad illnesses and infections. Prevention rests on Cognitive Behavior Therapy, which teaches the individual to exercise daily and
to think and prepare his mind before engaging in any form of eating. Unfortunately, success depends on the
individual’s abilities to learn new, life-altering ways.
3. Diabetes (fasting blood sugar
>125mg/dl) begins as pre-diabetes (fasting blood sugar 100-125mg/dl). During this early stage, it is entirely
preventable with exercise and weight loss. If the individual will just walk one hour a day and reduce
his weight, his pre-diabetes may never progress to diabetes. Exercise and weight reduction reverse
insulin resistance, which is the most important metabolic derangement in early
diabetes. Preventing diabetes also
prevents all its well-known complications such as blindness, gangrene of digits,
and renal failure.
4. Hyperlipidemias (high cholesterol &
triglycerides) are major causes of heart attacks, strokes, and poor blood
supply to the vital organs and extremities. They, like high blood pressure, cause no symptoms and are
not detectable without blood tests.
Cholesterol lowering medications are safe and very effective in
preventing the many types of vascular obstructions caused by
hyperlipidemia. Resistance to
treatment is based on irrational fears of medicines. There is clear scientific evidence that medical treatment
saves, prolongs, and improves the quality of life and has no long-term side
effects. In spite of that, medical
therapy is often resisted by those who can easily afford it. Such fears of medicines are major
obstacles against disease prevention.
5. Prostate cancer becomes common after
age 50. Most cases are detectable
at an early stage by physical examination of the prostate and the PSA (Prostate
Specific Antigen) blood test. The
science of prostate cancer is still in evolution and, consequently, it is not
yet known which form of treatment gives the best results. Moreover, prostate microscopy
(pathology) is not always capable of telling us which cancers will be
aggressive and which will be passive.
This presents another therapeutic problem because the passive cancers
may be compatible with a normal life span and may not require treatment. It is well known that as men age, more
and more of them will harbor small prostate cancers that may not affect the
longevity or quality of their lives.
Until more scientific studies are completed, opinion will remain divided
about what constitutes the best treatment approach.
6. Colon cancer, a major killer after age
50, is 90% preventable with colonoscopy.
It tends to begin in polyps and it takes an individual polyp 5-10 years
to become cancerous. Colonoscopy
at age 50, if it finds polyps, classifies the individual as a polyp maker,
excises the polyps, and places the individual under appropriate surveillance. Smokers, individuals with family
history of colon cancers, obese individuals, and sedentary individuals are at
an increased risk of developing colon cancers. All those who can afford a colonoscopy should have it done
when they turn fifty.
7. Ovarian cancer is another major killer
but, unfortunately, remains undetectable in its early stages. Pelvic examination, pelvic ultrasound,
pap smears, and the CEA blood test do not find it early enough to save
lives. The CEA blood test is
especially inadequate because it has too many false positives and false
negatives and should not be utilized as a routine screening test because it causes confusion and worry.
Even surgical removal of the ovaries does not totally prevent ovarian
cancer. Unless a test is developed
that can detect ovarian cancer in its early stages, this disease will remain
largely unpreventable.
8. Breast cancer is relatively preventable with mammography but mainly between the
ages of 50 and 75. We are not sure
that mammography done between the ages of 40 and 50 or after 75 saves enough
lives to make it mandatory. Breast
self examination, which is how many cancers are discovered, often finds them
too late. The mammography age rules may not
apply to women with a strong family history of breast cancer. Certain blood tests that detect such
breast cancer genes may guide such women to have their breasts removed as a
preventive measure, even though such surgery may not give perfect results.
9. Cervical cancer is readily preventable
with Pap smears that are done during pelvic examinations. It is a sexually transmitted disease
caused by certain strains of the HP virus. A Pap smear is not necessary in women who have never had sex
or in those who have had an elective hysterectomy (surgical removal of the uterus)
because they no longer have a cervix. However, women who have had a hysterectomy because of a cervical malignancy will still need to have Pap smears.
10. Lung cancer is common in smokers and is
seldom detected at the stage when it is curable. Chest x-rays, which were thought to be sensitive detectors,
have proven inadequate and useless.
Scientific studies have shown that doing annual chest x-rays on smokers
does not detect lung cancers early enough to save or prolong lives and seems to
do more harm than good. Hence, a
chest x-ray should only be done for symptoms and not for prevention. Other more sensitive tests such as CT
scans are under study but the results are not out yet. At present, the most important
preventive measure against lung cancer is to stop smoking. Stopping smoking also reduces cancers
of the mouth, larynx, esophagus, stomach, kidneys, and urinary bladder. Moreover, it also reduces the incidence
of heart attacks, strokes, aneurisms, pneumonias, asthma, and progressive lung
damage.
11. Osteoporosis, the leading cause of
vertebral, hip, and other arm-and-leg fractures is easily preventable. In women it begins after menopause and
in men, after age 65. Vitamin D
deficiency is a common cause and so is sedentary life (i.e. not taking daily
walks) and inadequate intake of calcium.
A bone density is diagnostic and therapy is quite effective. An adequate intake of calcium (1200
mg/day), vitamin D (1000 u/day), and daily one-hour walks are essential for
those at risk. Specific
medications are available that can reverse osteoporosis but their use in the
pre-osteoporosis stage (i.e. osteopenia) has not been shown to reduce fractures
and is not universally recommended.
12. Vaccines have great preventive powers
and all modern vaccines are safe, effective, and should be given as recommended
to both children and adults. There
are no scientifically rational arguments against vaccines and those who refuse
them do so because of imaginary fears.
The one annual vaccine that everyone should take is Influenza because epidemics occur annually and cause a
pronounced rise in mortality and morbidity worldwide. The myth that the Influenza vaccine can cause Influenza is
unfounded because the vaccine does not contain any living virus. Patients who say that every time they
are vaccinated they get influenza should be informed that the vaccine takes 3-4
weeks to become effective and that, during this vulnerable period, they may
actually succumb to other viral illnesses including Influenza. Moreover, many patients think that every viral infection is
the flu. In fact, the
flu only refers to Influenza, which is a
severe illness marked by very high fever, severe chills, severe body aches, and
a slow, protracted recovery. Most
patients who assume that they have had the flu will have actually had one of
the lesser, seasonal respiratory viral infections. On the other hand, patients who have had the real flu (i.e.
Influenza), never forget their horrible experience as long as they live.
To
conclude, while medical treatments help individuals, preventive treatments save
millions of lives and are epidemiologically crucial for the health of
nations. Like unhealthy
individuals, unhealthy nations slowly die, and history abounds with such
examples. Moreover, with modern
advances in technology, global health has become inseparable from national
health and, therefore, if we allow entire nations to succumb to preventable
diseases, planet earth will be our next victim. Sir Winston Chruchill was right when he said, "Healthy citizens are the
greatest asset any country can have."