Fear in Medicine/April 2008
Conceptually,
according to Bolles and Fanselow, fear and pain may be thought of as distinct, competitive,
motivational systems that modify perception and behavior, with fear being
dominant. What actually provokes
the fear response is the expectancy of pain and not the pain itself. This pain expectancy or worry is known
as Anticipatory Anxiety.
Pain
is suffering, and suffering is painful.
Pain is usually perceived as physical suffering whereas suffering, as
emotional pain. Nevertheless, all
suffering and all pain are caused by loss, the loss of what is dear to us. “I further maintain that sorrow
comes of loving what I cannot have,” said
Meister Eckhart (AD 1260-1328).
Physical
suffering is usually caused by the loss of health while emotional suffering, by
the loss of what we have come to love, cherish, dream of, struggle for, and
care about.
Fear
may be real or imaginary, rational or irrational. Imaginary or irrational fear is often harder to allay than
real or rational fear. This is so
because rational fear may yield to reason whereas irrational fear resists
evidence and logic. “The thing
I fear most is fear,” said Michel De
Montaigne (AD 1533-1592).
In
medicine, imaginary or irrational fear is a common confounder that often
interferes with evidence-based treatments that prevent disease, improve health,
and save lives. Most patients who
resist taking medications for Cholesterol, High Blood Pressure, Diabetes,
Addiction, Mental Illness, etc. or those who refuse Vaccines, Blood Tests,
Medical Investigations, Preventive Examinations, Surgical Interventions etc. do
so because of imaginary fears, and they utilize denial, delusion, and
justification to reinforce their contentions.
On
the other side of science lurk multibillion-dollar industries that promote
supplements and herbal products lacking valid efficacy and safety data. The popularity of these
non-evidence-based supplemental products is proportional to the prevalent fears
regarding the loss of health and youth among peoples. Pervasive, delusional beliefs in the occult powers of such
supplemental products approach mythological proportions and seem to be growing
exponentially in irreversible, revolutionary patterns that defy the unyielding
realities of modern science. The words
of Petronius (27-66 AD) “It was fear in the world that first made Gods,” are even more poignant today than they were in Roman
times when mythology, instead of science, provided all the explanations of
life’s tragedies and the natural phenomena.
And
while rational fears may be tempered with debate, education, and reassurance,
irrational fears require dedicated Cognitive Therapy before they may by
allayed. Cognitive Therapy aims to
undermine personal biases and to reduce personal resistance to evidence by
helping patients see the logical errors inherent in their faulty
reasoning. This is necessary
because all frightened people, and that includes all of us, seem to “reason
correctly but from the wrong precepts”. Unfortunately, Cognitive Therapy
can only be taught to motivated, open-minded patients. If the patient is incapable or
unmotivated, the fear state, with all its distortions of reality, persists
unabated and undermines health and the quality of life.
Fear
is a mental fire; when it is not extinguished from the outset, it rages wild
and becomes uncontrollable. “Then
fear drives out all wisdom from my heart,”
said Quintus Ennius (BC 239-169).
A good doctor first treats his patient’s fear and then he treats the
disease.